Not every coin in your pocket change is ordinary. In fact, one 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Liberty $1 coin recently shocked collectors when it sold for $4,200 at auction. The surprising discovery happened in a Georgia thrift store, proving that even a simple dollar coin can turn out to be a hidden treasure.
Let’s explore why this coin is so valuable, what makes it special, and how you can tell if you might have one.
A Hidden Gem Found in Spare Change
A thrift store employee in Georgia spotted a shiny dollar coin while counting cash donations. At first, it looked like an ordinary Susan B. Anthony dollar, but its unusual proof-like finish stood out.
After being authenticated, the coin went to auction in Atlanta where bidding started at $1,000. Collectors quickly drove the price up to $4,200, with the winning buyer calling it a “dream coin.”
Why the 1999 Susan B. Anthony Dollar Is Valuable
The Susan B. Anthony dollar was minted between 1979–1981 and briefly again in 1999. Most are common, but certain 1999-P coins are highly sought after because they have a rare proof-like appearance.
Here’s what makes them stand out:
- A mirror-like reflective surface
- Sharp, detailed features
- Extremely limited numbers struck
Because of their rarity, top-condition examples have sold for thousands. Some experts estimate that the finest proof-like versions could be worth $10,000 or more.
Key Features of the Valuable 1999 Susan B. Anthony Dollar
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Year | 1999 |
| Mint Mark | P (Philadelphia) |
| Type | Proof-like Susan B. Anthony Dollar |
| Mintage | Very limited (exact unknown) |
| Recent Auction Price | $4,200 |
How to Spot a Valuable 1999 Susan B. Anthony Dollar
Think you might have one of these rare coins? Here’s what to check:
- Look for the year 1999 with a “P” mint mark (Philadelphia).
- Examine the surface – proof-like coins have a shiny, mirror-like finish.
- Inspect for minting errors such as off-center strikes or doubled letters.
- Get it authenticated by a grading service like PCGS or NGC.
Even regular 1999-P Susan B. Anthony dollars in nice condition can be worth $5 to $20, while proof-like or error versions could bring in hundreds or even thousands.
Auction Buzz: From Pocket Change to $4,200
The Georgia thrift store find created a stir among coin collectors. Bidding was intense, starting at $1,000 and ending at $4,200. The buyer, a collector from Texas, said its mirror-like finish and near-perfect condition made it stand out from the crowd.
The Coin Hunt Is On
Since the auction, more collectors and everyday people are double-checking their change, thrift store finds, and old wallets. Because the Susan B. Anthony dollar is similar in size to a quarter, many people overlook it. But with the right mint mark and condition, it could be worth far more than a dollar.
FAQ: 1999 Susan B. Anthony Dollar Value
Q: What makes the 1999 P Susan B. Anthony coin valuable?
A: Its rarity, proof-like surface, and near-perfect condition make it highly sought after by collectors.
Q: Are all 1999 Susan B. Anthony dollars rare?
A: No. Most are common, but special proof-like or error versions can be worth thousands.
Q: How do I know if mine is proof-like?
A: Look for a shiny, mirror-like finish and sharper details compared to normal coins.
Q: Should I get my coin graded?
A: Yes. Professional grading can confirm authenticity and increase value.
Q: How much can a regular 1999 Susan B. Anthony be worth?
A: Typically between $5 and $20, but rare versions can reach $10,000.
Final Thoughts
The story of the 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Liberty $1 coin proves that valuable treasures can be hiding in plain sight. What looked like an ordinary dollar turned into a $4,200 windfall for one lucky thrift store clerk.
So, the next time you come across a Susan B. Anthony dollar, don’t overlook it. Check the mint mark, year, and condition carefully—you could be holding a small coin worth a fortune.